Pros and Cons in Education: Professionals and Con-Artists, that is
Teaching is hard. There are things I like about it: like the times that my class has a discussion about something they feel strongly about. I love being able to ask them questions and watch them think about it. I like watching their opinions change and evolve as they discuss and debate about things.
Of course, I like the students who come up and just smile at me, too. Some kids are gifts from Jesus because they just love me like I love them. Some of them. Some are apple-polishers, pure and simple! Lol!
I've got 7th, 8th, 9th, 10th, and 12th graders. A total of about 20 hours in the classroom each week, plus some extra hours in spent in extra-curricular clubs and activities. It's challenging.
As for the rest of teaching, the lesson prepping is getting easier. But it's still hard. Of course, there are staff meetings. Some meetings are really interesting. Others are, well, not. Staff meetings will always be just that, staff meetings.
And then there is "the catalog". This is the curse of all Moldovan teachers. It is the official register where teachers enter the students' marks. Teachers are also supposed to enter each of their lessons (name, date, and homework.) These two tasks are problematic for different reasons.
Entering the name, etc of each of my lessons isn't so bad, except that the name of each lesson should cross-reference exactly with another document that I've written, my "Long Term Lesson Plan," in which I detailed every lesson that I will teach, the date I'll teach it on, and the homework I'll give. Sort of an over-the-top pacing calendar that teachers must write for themselves.
Let that just sink in a bit.
I agree that a pacing calendar is a good thing. But this system is so full of red-tape. If my class gets audited in-depth by the Ministry of Education, I could catch h-e-double-l if I'm not teaching exactly the lesson I said I would on a particular day. So if my kids don't get something in the allotted time, I'm not (supposedly) allowed to go back and spend another lesson on that topic again.
It's the law (no kidding.) But it's horse-puckey. (Hey, that's a good word! I should teach that one in my class!) Welcome to a post-soviet culture influenced by centralized everything! (But good teachers go back anyway, and just make it look like they were following all the rules. Again, welcome to the state of bureacracy!)
And then there's the grading system. Being a first year teacher in the Moldovan system, I can't help but feel that it's totally subjective! Of course, I know that any grading system is subjective to a certain degree, even in America.
Let me give you an overview. Teachers give several students a mark at the end of each hour (jr and sr high) based on the student's performance in class or on the previous night's homework. Then, at the end of the semester, all the student's marks are straight averaged. No weighted averages allowed to make test marks, or homework, or a final project, more important in the overall grade.
I've heard about corruption in schools where students will pay off the teachers to give them good marks. I feel very fortunate that I have not seen anything like that at my school. We have great students, and wonderful teachers. I appreciate my colleagues' work more every day, as their well-informed, respectful students sit in my classroom day after day. I also appreciate my students, as I watch their bright, curious minds, and see many of them working hard in my class.
However, I'm still struggling with how to give grades in a way that doesn't seem absolutely subjective to me. I feel like a jerk when I give good marks OR when I give bad marks. Calling all professional teachers! I need a system that's feasible, that let's me weight the student's work in a way that I feel is appropriate, and is also legal in Moldova!
Of course, I like the students who come up and just smile at me, too. Some kids are gifts from Jesus because they just love me like I love them. Some of them. Some are apple-polishers, pure and simple! Lol!
I've got 7th, 8th, 9th, 10th, and 12th graders. A total of about 20 hours in the classroom each week, plus some extra hours in spent in extra-curricular clubs and activities. It's challenging.
As for the rest of teaching, the lesson prepping is getting easier. But it's still hard. Of course, there are staff meetings. Some meetings are really interesting. Others are, well, not. Staff meetings will always be just that, staff meetings.
And then there is "the catalog". This is the curse of all Moldovan teachers. It is the official register where teachers enter the students' marks. Teachers are also supposed to enter each of their lessons (name, date, and homework.) These two tasks are problematic for different reasons.
Entering the name, etc of each of my lessons isn't so bad, except that the name of each lesson should cross-reference exactly with another document that I've written, my "Long Term Lesson Plan," in which I detailed every lesson that I will teach, the date I'll teach it on, and the homework I'll give. Sort of an over-the-top pacing calendar that teachers must write for themselves.
Let that just sink in a bit.
I agree that a pacing calendar is a good thing. But this system is so full of red-tape. If my class gets audited in-depth by the Ministry of Education, I could catch h-e-double-l if I'm not teaching exactly the lesson I said I would on a particular day. So if my kids don't get something in the allotted time, I'm not (supposedly) allowed to go back and spend another lesson on that topic again.
It's the law (no kidding.) But it's horse-puckey. (Hey, that's a good word! I should teach that one in my class!) Welcome to a post-soviet culture influenced by centralized everything! (But good teachers go back anyway, and just make it look like they were following all the rules. Again, welcome to the state of bureacracy!)
And then there's the grading system. Being a first year teacher in the Moldovan system, I can't help but feel that it's totally subjective! Of course, I know that any grading system is subjective to a certain degree, even in America.
Let me give you an overview. Teachers give several students a mark at the end of each hour (jr and sr high) based on the student's performance in class or on the previous night's homework. Then, at the end of the semester, all the student's marks are straight averaged. No weighted averages allowed to make test marks, or homework, or a final project, more important in the overall grade.
I've heard about corruption in schools where students will pay off the teachers to give them good marks. I feel very fortunate that I have not seen anything like that at my school. We have great students, and wonderful teachers. I appreciate my colleagues' work more every day, as their well-informed, respectful students sit in my classroom day after day. I also appreciate my students, as I watch their bright, curious minds, and see many of them working hard in my class.
However, I'm still struggling with how to give grades in a way that doesn't seem absolutely subjective to me. I feel like a jerk when I give good marks OR when I give bad marks. Calling all professional teachers! I need a system that's feasible, that let's me weight the student's work in a way that I feel is appropriate, and is also legal in Moldova!
3 Comments:
It would seem that your best source of information would be the other teachers around you. The question you ask of them must not make it seem as if you're asking for help though, this might come across as a weakness on your part. But you're there to learn as well as teach!
TGED
Hey Emily;
Glad to see a new entry!
I struggle with the grading thing too. I have had many semesters when everyone received an A in my Wastewater treatment Operations course...quite possible when you score on a point system.
And at Shasta, if they don't drop themselves by a certain date, I have to give them an F! I hate that!
The first day handout sets the tone for the grading: Attendence and class particaption 10%, (I seldom penalize studetns if they can't make it...Life Happens,just get the homework in before the end of the semester.) Homework 40% Midterm and Final = 50%. Each assignement is so many points etc. The midterm and final are significant works so they are more points as well as half of the grade. I use an excell spread sheet to track it all. I use 85% as the cut off for an A and 75% for a B. I always have plenty of extra credit so points missed on the homework or tests can be earned back to some degree.
Sounds like you have a very difficult and foregin system of grading and what happens if they do audit you and find something not as planned? Do they take your time off away from you? I hope NOT!
Far be it from me to suggest anything to any full time teacher, I am just passing on what has been the practice in my class at Shasta JC. But then they come to my class to learn shit and rest! Ha!
Ciao Emily
volevo farti i complimenti hai un sito bellissimo un abbraccio dall'Italia
Elisa
Congratulations on a beautiful website
Loved everything on your site and you did a magnificent job. You should be proud of yourself
Post a Comment
<< Home